Lost in translation: who fueled the Duterte – Obama misunderstanding?

I have always expressed exasperation over our local media’s proclivity at sensationalism, especially when it comes to political issues. But when foreign media tries to put words into our mouths, the feeling goes beyond exasperation. The effect gets more ominous. A quick google search about President Duterte’s alleged cursing of Obama led me to these headlines by supposedly credible foreign media:

sob1.jpgsob2.jpg

 

 

 

sob4.jpg

 

sob4.jpg

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

This allegedly started when a reporter asked Duterte a hypothetical question that went something like this: “IF Obama brings up the subject of EJK, what will you say to him?”. The President’s reply, in his usual passionate but crude manner, was what most foreign media mistranslated, leading to the headlines above. I have yet to see a full video of Duterte’s reply to that reporter’s question, but here is a transcript of that reply that an FB contact shared on his timeline:

Transcript:

PRES. DUTERTE: You know, the Philippines is not a vassal state. We have long ceased to be a colony of the United States. Alam mo, marami diyan, sa mga kolumnista, they look upon Obama and the United States as if we are the lap dogs of this country. I do not respond to anybody but to the people of the Republic of the Philippines. Wala akong pakialam sa kaniya. Who is he? When as a matter of a fact, at the turn of the century, before the Americans left the Philippines in the pacification campaign of the Moro in this island, there were about six million ang population ng Moro. How many died? Six hundred. If he can answer that question and give the apology, I will answer him.

I am not beholden to anybody. Iyong mga kolumnista diyan na ‘wait until he meets,’ who is he? I am a President of a sovereign state, and we have long ceased to be a colony. I do not have any master, except the Filipino people, nobody but nobody. 

You must be respectful. Do not just throw questions and statements. Putang-ina, mumurahin kita diyan sa forum na ‘yan. Huwag mo akong ganunin. Tell that to everybody. Itong mga kolumnista, para ba akong tinatakot, anak ka ng — umalis kayo diyan sa Pilipinas, pumunta kayo doon sa Amerika. You write kung ano nasa isip — the lap dogs of this American. Who is he to confront me? As a matter of fact, he has too many –America has one too many to answer for the misdeeds in this country. Hanggang ngayon hindi pa tayo nakatikim ng apology niyan. That is the reason why Mindanao continues to boil.

Sabi mo that was the last century, ‘yang wounds na ‘yan from generation to generation. As a matter of fact, we inherited this problem from the United States. Why? Because they invaded this country and made us their subjugated people. Everybody has a terrible record of extrajudicial killings. Why make an issue about fighting crime? Hindi nga niya maubus-ubos ‘yan sa Mexico border niya. Look at the human rights of America along that line, the way how they treat the migrants there. Masyado kayong bilib sa Amerika, bumilib kayo dito sa atin, ano iyang America. Siya ang mag-explain sa akin kung bakit ganun extrajudicial killing nila. Can he explain the 600,000 Moro massacred in this island? Do you want to see the pictures? Maybe, you’ll ask him, and make it public. We have a recorded history of that sordid period of our national life.

Nobody but nobody can just—sino ka? ‘Yung mga American-Indian sa sine lang inubos mo eh. What about the rights of those guys who died in the past? Is it because it’s just the past tense we do not answer for the present tense? You must be kidding. Stop joking yourself. Kayong mga sobra kabilib diyan—who is Obama to ask me that? I’ll tell him, who are you? Tell him that, telegraph mo ngayon. Hindi ako punta dito, magpaka-ulila diyan sa mga…

We have long been a Republic. I do not — I said, I do not kneel down before anybody else, except the Filipino in Quiapo walking in misery and in extreme poverty and hunger. Hindi kayo maghinto diyan sa droga—the campaign against drugs will continue. Maraming mamatay diyan, plenty will be killed until the last pusher is out of the streets. Until the drug manufacturer is killed, we will continue and I will continue, and I don’t give a shit about anybody observing my behavior. Sige lang mabilib kayo diyan. ‘Yung mga column nag-bash, susmaryosep! Pagka-lap dog ng mga–pretending to be the conscience of this–sino ka? Hindi ako bilib diyan sa America. Gusto mo sipain ko pa ‘yan sa harap mo eh. Pumunta kayo doon.

Here is Rappler’s transcript, claiming to be the “official” one, still with loose English translation for the sake of English readers.

I don’t know about you, but I can’t find the part where the President called Obama a “son of a bitch”. GetRealPhilippines‘ benigno gave an accurate translation of the controversial line that the media is alluding to. Sadly, even CNN Philippines got it wrong.

Screen Shot 2016-09-07 at 12.30.57 PM.png

Now, check CBS News’ link from the screenshot above. It will take you to a different headline, and what appears to be a corrected version of the story, putting President Duterte’s words into proper context. That’s pride with responsibility — tweaking the headline and revising the report to be as close to the fact as possible. I can accept that.

(UPDATE: A local TV broadcast journalist, Ed Lingao recently posted a personal apology for an erroneous report that he read about the alleged Duterte cursing. What an honorable man!)

What’s even more infuriating about this whole thing is that Filipino netizens, again, are showing their usual crassness with their uninformed opinions. This is what foreign media, and CNN Philippines, has done. Heaven knows where this will lead if the media does not correct themselves or at least admit to the inaccuracy of the translation. Our fate and future as Filipinos and as allies of the United States are on the line here.

The damage has been done. I could only hope that every thinking Filipino — netizen or not — and world leaders like Obama will have a grain of salt handy whenever they digest “news” from reporters, local or foreign.

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s